Dimon's pledge to recoup the UK bank tax is a threat, not an argument
A bank tax can be criticised on its merits, but vowing to offset it to teach governments a lesson answers nothing and deserves a evidence-based reply.
Watch in 41 seconds
Key points
- Dimon's stated aim is to set an example for governments, which is retaliation, not analysis of the tax.
- The strongest objection to the tax is real: costs may land on customers, staff or UK investment rather than shareholders.
- Ministers should publish the evidence, and JPMorgan should say exactly what it will change, so both can be judged.
Jamie Dimon is entitled to call the UK's increased bank tax unfair, but his chosen response, finding ways to offset it so that governments learn the trade-offs of such penalties, is the wrong way to contest it. A tax should stand or fall on its design and its effects. A promise to recoup the money, framed as a lesson, tells us about the bank's bargaining posture and nothing about whether the levy is sound.
The case against the tax deserves a hearing. Supporters of Dimon's position argue that banks are a vital part of the economy, that they are already taxed heavily compared with other companies, and that they make an easy target because the public has little sympathy for them. If a levy cuts the return on UK activity, they say, firms will shift staff, assets or lending elsewhere, and the Exchequer will collect less than it hoped. That is a legitimate economic argument, and a government that ignores it risks a policy that looks good on the day it is announced and costs more later.
But it is an argument about outcomes, and Dimon has not made it. The reporting gives no figure for the cost of the increase to his bank, no description of how he would claw it back, and no indication of which customers, products or jobs would bear the cost. Without those details, "offset" could mean anything from trimming bonuses to raising fees to moving operations abroad. Those are very different results for the UK, and the public cannot weigh them while the threat remains vague.
The stated motive makes the problem worse. If the aim is to set an example for other governments, then the response is calibrated to send a message, not to correct a mistake in the tax. Companies lobby governments all the time, and that is normal. Announcing in advance that you will make a policy hurt, to deter its imitators, is a different thing, and it invites the reply that a tax which provokes such a response is doing something. It also gives ministers an easy way to dismiss every genuine objection as self-interest.
That does not let the government off. Ministers chose to raise this tax and should be able to show the evidence for it: how much it is expected to raise, who is expected to pay it, and what assumptions about lending, pricing and relocation sit behind those numbers. The reporting does not give us that analysis, so we cannot say whether the levy is well judged. A tax that is defended only by pointing to the size of a bank's profits is as weakly argued as an objection that rests only on the size of its influence.
The sensible way forward is plain. The Treasury should publish its impact assessment, including its estimate of how much of the cost is likely to pass to customers and staff. JPMorgan should say, concretely and in advance, what it intends to change in the UK and by how much. And the government should commit to a review after a fixed period, comparing the revenue raised with the forecast and the observed effects on lending, so that the tax can be adjusted if it is hurting the wrong people. Both sides then argue from the same numbers, and the public can judge which of them was right.
This editorial is the view of Global Eye 24, written with AI assistance. Spot an error? Write to corrections@globaleye24.com.