Ukraine's own drone links show why no army should depend on one private network
Kyiv's move away from Starlink for drone strikes shows that military communications must never hinge on one company's goodwill or one government's permission.
Watch in 43 seconds
Key points
- Repeated Starlink disruptions pushed Ukraine to build its own drone communications, which then helped in a strike on a bridge Russia relies on.
- Starlink's scale is real, but dependence on a single private provider is a strategic weakness whatever its quality.
- Allies should fund and standardise multiple independent links and write continuity guarantees into contracts.
Ukraine's use of its own communication system for drone strikes, after repeated disruptions to Starlink, should end any serious army's willingness to rely on one commercial network for combat operations. The system, built around what Kyiv calls flying modems, was used in the attack that took down a bridge Moscow depended on. Whatever else it shows, it demonstrates that a country under pressure can build a workable alternative faster than many assumed.
The core problem is not that Starlink is poor technology. It is that a front-line capability was exposed to interruptions that Ukraine could neither predict nor control. A link that can be throttled, restricted or switched off by a private company, or by a government with leverage over it, is not a dependable part of a military plan. Commanders cannot sequence an offensive around a service that may degrade for reasons they are not told.
It is also unclear who was responsible for the disruptions. Accounts differ on whether the decisions rested with the company or with parts of the US government, and officials and the company have pointed at each other. We think this uncertainty is itself the strongest argument for change: when nobody can say with confidence who holds the switch, no planner can rely on the service. Ambiguity over control is a defect in any system that carries targeting data.
The strongest counter-argument runs as follows. Starlink offers coverage, bandwidth and speed of deployment that no national programme can quickly match, and it has been valuable to Ukraine's forces since early in the war. Building and fielding a parallel system is costly, may be less capable, and could fragment allied equipment into incompatible standards. On this view, the sensible course is to keep the commercial network and negotiate firmer terms with its owner.
That case is right about the value of the network, and we do not argue that Ukraine should abandon it. But it answers a different question. The issue is not whether Starlink is useful, but whether it should be the only route when lives and strategic targets depend on it. Ukraine's experience suggests that a cheaper, domestically controlled link can cover the most sensitive tasks, while the commercial network remains available for the broad, less critical traffic where its scale counts. Redundancy costs money, but so does a stalled operation.
What should happen next is specific. Allied governments that supply Ukraine should fund its sovereign communication systems directly and help standardise them so units from different countries can use them together. Contracts with any commercial provider supporting military operations should include written continuity terms, including notice periods and a clear statement of who may restrict service and on what grounds. Procurement rules in NATO members should require that no critical function rests on a single supplier or a single point of control.
European defence ministries, in particular, should treat Ukraine's system as a field-tested design to be examined and, where it holds up, adopted. The lesson is not about any one company or leader. A communications link that a military cannot guarantee is a borrowed capability, and the sooner allies stop treating it as a permanent one, the less exposed their forces will be.
This editorial is the view of Global Eye 24, written with AI assistance. Spot an error? Write to corrections@globaleye24.com.