OpinionThe debatePolicy

Should Britain try to rejoin the European Union?

A decade after the referendum, Leavers say rejoining is unwinnable and costly, while Remainers say the price of staying out keeps rising.

Watch in 46 seconds

Key points

  • Rejoining would restore trade, investment and influence at a time when the UK has no growth to show for leaving and the US is less reliable.
  • The UK has adapted, the EU has changed, and rejoining would mean accepting rules the UK cannot shape, plus free movement and probably the euro.
  • Whether a Labour leader is willing to open the question, and what polling shows once actual terms are on the table.

Ten years after the 2016 referendum, in which 17.4 million people voted to leave, the question of returning has moved from the fringe into mainstream Labour politics. Burnham, a prominent Labour figure, now faces pressure over whether to open it. Leave campaigners, by their own reckoning, cannot win a head-on battle over rejoining. Their strategy is to make it politically costly enough that Labour never starts one.

The argument is no longer only about the past. It turns on what the UK would be rejoining, what it has built since leaving, and whether a world with a less dependable America changes the calculation. Evidence is contested, and some of the figures in circulation are of uncertain origin, so they are best treated with care.

The case for

The economic record of leaving is poor, and rejoining is the most direct repair. Supporters say the UK has lagged the EU and the eurozone on growth per head since 2016, and especially since 2020. They add that the promised gains, including better control of immigration, have not clearly materialised. The precise figures vary by source and some are disputed, but the direction of the argument is that the UK is not better off for having left. Returning to the single market would remove frictions the country chose to impose on itself.

The geopolitical case has strengthened. With the United States seen as increasingly unpredictable, advocates argue that Britain's security and economic interests are better served by sitting at the table with Germany, France and Italy as an equal than by drifting alone. They say the choice is no longer between the EU and independence, but between Europe and dependence on Washington.

Public opinion is said to be on their side. Rejoin supporters cite polling suggesting a large majority, put at 63% in one cited survey, now favours returning. They say a democratic mandate to leave in 2016 does not bind a country indefinitely, particularly when those who campaigned for it offered no plan for the economic damage and, in the supporters' telling, misrepresented the stakes.

Waiting only extends the cost. Advocates argue that a decade has already been lost, and that every further year of delay adds to it. Some are prepared to accept the euro and renewed free movement, seeing the latter as a benefit, since it also opens the continent to British people who want to work, study or retire there.

The case against

The EU the UK would rejoin is not the one it left. Critics, including some who voted Remain, argue that the bloc is now more fragmented, internally divided and without a clear direction. They fear the UK would pay heavily to rejoin and then be a rule-taker, with less control over its own affairs than it has today.

The trade case is weaker than it looks. Opponents say exports of goods and services to the EU have risen since 2025, that services make up about 60% of UK exports, and that key sectors such as machinery, drinks and cars send more than 60% of their exports outside the EU. They also note that the EU's share of the world economy has shrunk, and question how much a single market is worth, especially given that services are far from fully integrated within it. These figures are asserted rather than verified here.

Rejoining the single market means accepting free movement again. For many voters, immigration was central in 2016 and remains so. Critics argue that returning would reopen the UK to EU migration, and that any government attempting it would be punished by the same voters who delivered Brexit in the first place.

The sovereignty trade-off, and the politics of reopening the fight. Even some who regret Brexit argue the question is no longer whether it was a mistake but whether rejoining is the right remedy. They say the UK has adapted, that growth problems predate and outlast Brexit, and that a decade of renewed constitutional conflict would be a distraction from fixing an economy that is failing to deliver for most people either way.

What would settle it

A clear picture will emerge from the terms on offer. The EU has not set out what a returning UK would be asked to accept on the euro, budget contributions or free movement, and support for rejoining may look different once those are specified. Polling that tests actual terms, rather than the principle, would show how durable the reported majority is.

Trade and growth data will matter too. Sustained UK performance against the EU on output per head, and the trajectory of exports to the bloc, would test claims on both sides. Several figures cited in the debate are unsourced or disputed and would need checking against official statistics.

Finally, there is the political test: whether Burnham or any Labour leader is willing to put rejoining in a manifesto, and whether voters reward or punish them for it at an election.

The strongest arguments on each side, set out by the Global Eye 24 desk with AI assistance. Spot an error? Write to corrections@globaleye24.com.