OpinionThe Global Eye 24 view

Asia's summit week is not a new Yalta, and Europe should stop talking as if it were

The idea that Washington, Beijing and Moscow can divide the world among themselves flatters all three, and treating it as likely weakens everyone else's hand.

Watch in 39 seconds

Key points

  • The three leaders lack the means and the shared interests to carve up the world, so 'Yalta 2.0' is the wrong frame.
  • Sceptics are right that the label is a projection, but a loose frame still shapes expectations and negotiating positions.
  • Europe and Asian hosts should state their own terms before the summits end, especially on Ukraine.

We do not think Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin can divide the world among themselves, and we think commentators and governments should stop talking as though they might. This week's summits in China and the Philippines, with Mr Trump now in Asia and a meeting with Mr Xi and Mr Putin expected, will produce handshakes and possibly some bilateral deals. They will not produce a settlement of spheres of influence. The comparison with Yalta flatters the participants and misleads everyone else.

The historical analogy fails on its own terms. The 1945 conference brought together leaders who had just won a war and who each commanded the means to enforce what they agreed. Today's trio share no such common victory. Mr Putin's forces are still stuck in eastern Ukraine more than four years into a war that was meant to be short, and a Ukrainian strike on the Crimean Bridge, with rail traffic resuming only afterwards according to Russian sources, is a reminder of how contested even Russia's own supply lines are. Mr Trump, for his part, has just seen his political camp suffer a heavy midterm defeat, which limits what he can promise at home.

The strongest objection is that this is a straw man. Sceptics note that none of the leaders has said a carve-up is on the agenda, so inventing the idea only to knock it down is cheap. There is something in that: a headline-friendly label can manufacture a drama that the participants never intended. But the objection understates how much frames matter. Governments, markets and publics prepare for what they expect, and if the working assumption becomes that three capitals decide and the rest comply, smaller states will begin to behave as if that were true.

There is also a practical reason the three cannot bargain freely. Their interests overlap only at the margins. The United States and China compete over trade and technology, and Russia needs more from both than it can offer in return. Several of the places that matter most to any grand bargain, including Ukraine, the European Union and India, are not at the table at all. A deal that sidesteps them would need their acquiescence to hold, and nothing suggests they would give it.

That is why the useful response is to act, not to speculate. European governments should say plainly, before the summits end, that no arrangement affecting Ukraine's territory or security can be settled without Ukraine, and should be ready to back that with concrete commitments on aid and sanctions. The ASEAN hosts, who have given these meetings their stage, should use the occasion to press for outcomes that cover their own region's concerns, such as trade rules and maritime security, rather than serving as a backdrop.

And the rest of us should judge the week by what is actually signed. If the meetings yield specific, verifiable commitments, such as a ceasefire mechanism or tariff reductions with dates attached, they deserve scrutiny on their merits. If they yield only warm photographs and talk of a new order, they deserve to be treated as exactly that, and no more.

This editorial is the view of Global Eye 24, written with AI assistance. Spot an error? Write to corrections@globaleye24.com.