OpinionThe Global Eye 24 view

Nvidia's board should not bring Jensen Huang back while the Megaspeed questions are open

Lobbying to reinstate a chief executive who resigned over a scandal with national-security implications is the wrong basis for a decision that belongs to the board.

Watch in 46 seconds

Key points

  • A resignation over an alleged link to a Chinese spy should be settled by a review, not by lobbying from allies.
  • Arguing that the company cannot function without one man is evidence of a governance weakness, not a reason to ignore it.
  • The board should commission an independent review, publish its scope and decide on any return only once it reports.

Nvidia's board should refuse to reinstate Jensen Huang for now, and it should say so plainly. He resigned after an affair with an alleged Chinese spy, and allies in the technology industry are now pressing the directors to reverse that outcome. A decision of this kind should follow an independent examination of what happened, not a campaign run by people who are not accountable for the consequences.

Start with what is known and what is not. Huang left the company after the relationship came to light, and supporters are lobbying for his return. Separately, the US Treasury secretary, Scott Bessent, has blamed the Commerce Department under Howard Lutnick for the failure to blacklist Megaspeed, the firm at the centre of the affair. Whether Nvidia or Huang knew anything improper, whether any export rule was broken, and why Megaspeed stayed off the blacklist are all unsettled. That uncertainty is the main reason to wait.

The strongest case for a quick return rests on value and continuity. Huang built a company that is now central to the AI industry, his supporters say, and the personal conduct at issue should be weighed against that record. Nvidia's shareholders, the argument continues, would back him if asked, and a board that overrides them is putting its own judgement above the owners' interests. Chip and AI-infrastructure shares were already falling in early trading today, and some investors will fear that a drawn-out absence deepens the damage.

That case has real force on one point: the board answers to shareholders, and their view matters. But it fails on the logic. If the company cannot be run without one person, that is a risk the board is obliged to manage, not a credential that excuses the circumstances of his departure. Dependence on a single leader is exactly why directors must not let anyone, however important, set the terms of his own return.

The argument also confuses two questions. Whether Huang is a gifted leader is not in doubt. Whether the company has a full, credible account of its dealings with Megaspeed is a different matter, and an open one. Reinstating him before that account exists would invite regulators and customers to assume the board preferred stability to scrutiny. Share prices may recover faster than trust, and the company sells to governments and corporations that care about trust.

The political dimension adds to the case for care. Washington is now arguing about who failed to act on Megaspeed, and the dispute between Treasury and Commerce shows that the facts will be contested and will take time to establish. A board that restores its chief executive in the middle of that dispute would be placing a bet on how it ends. It would also hand any later finding a far greater impact on the company.

So the board should do three concrete things. First, appoint outside counsel to conduct an independent review of the Megaspeed relationship and Nvidia's export-control compliance, with terms published and a reporting date set. Second, keep the current interim arrangements in place until that review reports. Third, once it has, decide on Huang's future on the evidence, and if directors are minded to bring him back, put the question to shareholders with the findings in front of them. Allies who want him back should welcome that process, because a return that survives scrutiny is worth far more than one that avoids it.

This editorial is the view of Global Eye 24, written with AI assistance. Spot an error? Write to corrections@globaleye24.com.