OpinionThe Global Eye 24 view

Ukraine should not trade the Donbas fortress belt for a Nato promise

A pledge of membership is worth having, but only if it is binding before a single Ukrainian soldier leaves ground that Russia would otherwise struggle to take.

Watch in 43 seconds

Key points

  • Withdrawal is immediate and irreversible, while membership is a future promise that all allies must ratify.
  • The 1994 Budapest assurances show what guarantees are worth when the guarantor's interest changes.
  • Any deal should put accession first, include Europe at the table, and put the final choice to Ukrainians.

Ukraine should refuse any arrangement in which it leaves the Donbas before it is a member of Nato. President Zelenskyy says Washington has floated membership in return for a withdrawal, and that he will take the proposal to the Ukrainian people. They should be told plainly what is on offer: a concrete, permanent concession by Kyiv against an assurance that has not yet been written, ratified or tested.

The asymmetry is the heart of the matter. A withdrawal happens on a timetable and cannot be undone. Membership requires the agreement of every existing ally, and so far we know only that the United States is exploring terms. We do not know whether the offer is an invitation to join under Article 5, a lesser guarantee described in warmer language, or a negotiating position that other allies have not endorsed. Until that is clear, Kyiv would be paying in full for something it cannot yet inspect.

History counsels caution. In 1994 Ukraine gave up the nuclear weapons on its soil in return for written assurances from Russia, the United States, the United Kingdom and France. Russia later invaded, and the document proved to be of little protection. Critics of the new proposal also note that the settlement would leave Russia holding a fortified belt in the Donbas from which a later offensive could be launched, while Ukraine would have surrendered the defences that make such an offensive costly. Whether or not one accepts that Moscow would break a new deal, a settlement that depends on its good faith is a poor foundation.

The strongest argument for the proposal deserves a fair hearing. The war is costing Ukraine dearly: Russian strikes hit energy and rail infrastructure in eight regions overnight, and Moscow claims to be shooting down more than a thousand drones. Membership of Nato has been Kyiv's stated aim and Moscow's central objection, so a path to it would be a real strategic gain, and refusing it might cost Ukraine American support. Supporters add that territory lost in a negotiation is not necessarily lost for ever, whereas the alliance's collective defence would be a durable protection that no front line can offer.

That case is serious, but it does not survive the sequencing problem. If membership is as valuable as supporters say, it should be secured first. Nothing about the benefit requires Ukraine to move before the commitment exists. A further difficulty is credibility: membership means the same obligations as for any other member, including the forces and infrastructure that would make the commitment believable. Whether all allies, and the United States in particular, are prepared for that is precisely what has not been shown.

We therefore suggest what should happen next. Kyiv should insist that any accession agreement be signed and ratified by allies before any withdrawal begins, with verification and a mechanism that halts the process if Russia violates the terms. European governments, whose security is directly at stake, should agree on their own representative rather than accept Moscow's suggestion that it should approve who speaks for the continent. The text of whatever is offered should be published so that Ukrainians can judge it, because the decision to cede ground belongs to them, not to the negotiators. If Washington cannot put a binding commitment on the table, the right answer is no.

This editorial is the view of Global Eye 24, written with AI assistance. Spot an error? Write to corrections@globaleye24.com.